What To Think About Watchman?

First I have to say that I have not yet read Go Set a Watchman. I do intend to read it though; my copy arrived from Amazon yesterday. But the early reviews of Harper Lee’s second novel have been playing on my mind and I feel a need to set my thoughts down now.

As I said in a previous post, I was concerned that this “new” book would expose writing that wasn’t ready for publication, that maybe it just wouldn’t be very good. It never occurred to me that the beloved Atticus Finch could ever be anything but the paragon of handsome virtue Gregory Peck portrayed him to be. But is the racist, segregation-supporting Atticus of Watchman a first draft character that Lee totally discarded when she wrote To Kill a Mockingbird? Or was this darker man always there in her thoughts as she wrote the story from a child’s point of view? Was she intending to write a sequel where the adult Jean Louise would be disillusioned to discover the true nature of the father she had idolized?

Perhaps I’ll have a clearer answer after I read the book, but I want to believe that the former is true. I want to believe that Lee never released this book because the Atticus Finch of Watchman no longer existed. Maybe she’d thrown him out and invented a whole new guy for Mockingbird. Of course this is a very idealistic wish, and the fact is none of us will ever know what the answer is. Harper Lee is unwilling or—more likely—unable to tell us what she was thinking back then.

It’s occurred to me this past week that Atticus Finch has been a perfect, pure, unadulterated hero for all of us white progressives. At the risk of his reputation, his safety—and most importantly the safety of his children—he did the right thing, he stood up to the bigots in his town and defended an African American man unjustly accused of a crime. We all like to think we could perform as well, you know, if we were ever tested. And yet most of us design our lives so we won’t be tested, so we won’t have to confront our own bigotry. This is especially easy here out west where there are no Civil War battlefields or memorials to fallen Freedom Riders.

So here I will present a small test for my literary minded friends: how many books have you read lately by African American writers? How may books have you ever read by authors of color? I have to admit for myself, it’s not many. I will say that when I was first out of college, as a fledgling feminist and aspiring writer, I deliberately chose to mainly read books by women. I was looking for role models. Margaret Atwood and Barbara Kingsolver are now favorites, and I wouldn’t miss one of their novels as soon as they hit the shelves. I’ve read and enjoyed some of Toni Morrison’s work, but I’m sorry to say I can’t tell you what her last novel was called. And oh—I just remembered—I used to read each new book by Alice Walker, but at some point decades ago she fell off my radar too.

What’s really embarrassing is I don’t even know where to begin. Who are the up and coming young writers of color?

We can speculate forever about Harper Lee’s state of mind back when she was writing Watchman and Mockingbird, and about her cognitive health now. We’ll never know for sure. So let’s take the discussion in a new direction. It turns out Atticus Finch was a closet racist. Well, guess what, he’s not alone. Let’s expand our reading lists to include more ethnic diversity. I challenge you to help me out, to give me the names of novels to read and writers to watch for.

9 thoughts on “What To Think About Watchman?

  1. Probably way off base, but I had to put the darn book down. I thought the opening passage was disappointing bordering on dreadful. Exceedingly high expectations, no doubt.

    I will give it another try later…

    Best, your pal Bill

  2. wow, that’s discouraging, Bill! Right now I’m reading “All the Light We Cannot See,” which is beautifully poetic. Only a third of the way in, but I highly recommend it. In other news, Bill–are you going to the Mendocino conference next month? I’m too busy this year; hope to go again in 2016. Take good care!

  3. I have to say that when I learned that the Atticus Finch of Watchman presents as a racist, I was intrigued. I think most people are more complex than Mockingbird’s Atticus, and maybe the truth of Atticus – like most folks white, black, and whatever else, raised in 20th Century America – lies in some combination of the two characters. Hopefully, as we open up to experience we incline toward the “better angel of our nature,” but I think the daimon in all of us needs to be acknowledged. I haven’t read Watchman yet – I read more poetry and non-fiction these days – but I will probably read it to see what seems to be behind Harper Lee’s creation of this additional character, or perhaps, this additional dimension of the same character. Thanks for your post.

  4. At some point I plan to read “Watchman”, but I just finished re-reading “To Kill a Mockingbird” and I found Harper Lee’s writing in that book to be so extraordinary. Her descriptions of place and her development of characters was so well done. The voices of her characters were so well developed and rang true. It was easy to sink into the telling and feel like I was there in that time and place. I want to linger in that “magic” that she created, and I have the feeling that, from what others are saying, this new publication does not achieve the same excellence.
    A mystery writer that I enjoy and whose work I follow is Walter Mosley. Check him out.

  5. I just finished reading River Cross My Heart by Breena Clarke. It was her 1st novel and I look forward to her next. Written from the point of view of 11 year old Johnnie Mae Bynum, she relates the effects of the drowning of her little sister Clara on her and her extended family, which moved to Washington DC’s Georgetown area from N. Carolina. Clarke gently portrays the inherent social dynamics of the era (the mid-1920s). You will love this family.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.